The good, the bad and the stupid?

Im not really sure where im going with this as it might just be the lack of sleep but I decided to see what people thought of this picture and vote Good or Bad. Basing it on the quote by J.Webb.

Good that makes it good bad that makes it bad.

Then when you give an answer I want you tell me if you think that it is better or worse than the picture below with a reason why.

That's right mike look at the kitten.

I have worked out that although a picture or painting is better than that of another does not make it a master piece. FACT!